>> MCAD User News and Reviews
Thread views: 162408 View all threadsNext thread*

09/16/06 06:55 PM
Tolerance Analysis Redux [re: icconian]Report this article as Inappropriate to us !!!Login to Reply

There are a couple of comments I'd like to add.

First, on the issue of no theoretical VisVSA background material - keep in mind the following. VSA was a company purchased by Engineering Animation Inc. prior to EAI being purchased by UGS. VSA was primarily a consulting company that wrote software for the use of its consultants. VSA was never serious about the sale of software per se. As such, not only was there never any motive to document its software, anything that imparted knowledge to the users took consulting business away, so it was in VSA's best interests for this to remain a "mystery". It is Monte Carlo simulation based, which is about all anyone knows about it. Its subsequent owners had an appreciation for GD&T about equal to the average engineer, so its no surprise that information about it is limited.

Second, on the issue of the vector loop vs. Monte Carlo simulation. Vector loop methods are in general very fast, and the do not require actual shop floor results data to be effective. The tradeoff for this is that vector loop performance deteriorates rapidly as the size of the problem increases, and it does not take into account variability that is introduced as a result of variations due to manufactuing methods and machines. In all cases, IMHO a Monte-Carlo based simulation approach yields superior results, and can do so on very large problems (i.e a complicated assembly with corresponding tooling), but to be most effective requires results from shop floor operations to model the variation upon which Monte Carlo simulation depends.

Entire thread
SubjectPosted byPosted on
*Today's Culture in Tolerance Analysis Blocks Real Benefits  02/24/06 07:26 AM
.*Tolerance analysis is not a solid engineering/science yetPinsan Cheng  07/10/06 05:23 PM
.*Re: ToleranceJeremy Wright  07/12/06 01:21 PM
.*Re: Tolerance TedA   10/09/06 01:42 PM
.*Re: ToleranceTim McLellan  09/12/06 03:39 AM
.*Re: ToleranceJR Haag  10/03/06 08:32 AM
.*Re: ToleranceNorm  10/05/06 03:38 PM
.*You're right as usual!icconian  02/24/06 07:26 AM
.*Tolerance Analysis ReduxDavidO  09/16/06 06:55 PM
.*Looking for opportunity in Tolerance AnalysisSrini  11/29/06 11:45 AM
.*Re: Tolerance Analysis ReduxDave S.  11/07/06 08:09 PM
.*Re: Tolerance Analysis ReduxNorm  11/28/06 10:31 AM
.*Re: Tolerance Analysis Redux TedA   10/09/06 01:53 PM
.*Re: Tolerance Analysis ReduxTom R.  10/30/06 07:18 AM
.*Re: You're right as usual!Norm Crawford  03/01/06 10:28 AM
.*Re: You're right as usual! Sturdy   02/28/06 06:01 PM
Jump to


TurboCAD pro : Free Trial

Internet Business Systems © 2016 Internet Business Systems, Inc.
595 Millich Dr., Suite 216, Campbell, CA 95008
+1 (408)-337-6870 — Contact Us, or visit our other sites:
AECCafe - Architectural Design and Engineering EDACafe - Electronic Design Automation GISCafe - Geographical Information Services TechJobsCafe - Technical Jobs and Resumes ShareCG - Share Computer Graphic (CG) Animation, 3D Art and 3D Models
  Privacy Policy Advertise