[ Back ]   [ More News ]   [ Home ]
September 01, 2003
Patent Infringement Case Protects Rights of License Holder
Please note that contributed articles, blog entries, and comments posted on MCADcafe.com are the views and opinion of the author and do not necessarily represent the views and opinions of the management and staff of Internet Business Systems and its subsidiary web-sites.

by Amy Rowell - Contributing Editor
Each MCAD Weekly Review delivers to its readers news concerning the latest developments in the MCAD industry, MCAD product and company news, featured downloads, customer wins, and coming events, along with a selection of other articles that we feel you might find interesting. Brought to you by MCADCafe.com. If we miss a story or subject that you feel deserves to be included, or you just want to suggest a future topic, please contact us! Questions? Feedback? Click here. Thank you!


Patent Infringement Case Protects Rights of License Holder

by Amy A. Rowell

Court rules that 3D Systems infringed EOS GmbH patent rights

Apparently, it truly pays to buy the rights.

On August 20th, 2003 the United States District Court for the Central District of California ruled in favor of rapid prototyping manufacturer, EOS GmbH, in a patent infringement case that has been on the books for nearly three years. In December 2000, EOS GmbH filed a lawsuit against DTM Corporation of Austin, TX alleging that the Sinterstation and Vanguard laser-sintering rapid prototyping systems manufactured and sold by DTM Corporation, infringed patent rights held by EOS GmbH of Munich, Germany.

And in the final hour, the court sided with EOS GmbH.

3D Systems of California licensed certain rapid prototyping technologies to EOS GmbH in August 1997. As a result of this 1997 license agreement, EOS was licensed under the 3D Systems' patents to the extent the patents pertained to the field of laser sintering.

3D Systems later acquired DTM, in August 2001. And DTM, too, took advantage of this patented laser-sintering technology in the development of its Sinterstation and Vanguard laser-sintering rapid prototyping systems. Unfortunately, it didn't have the right to do so, based on the court's recent ruling.

Specifically, the Court ruled that one claim of one of the 13 asserted 3D Systems' patents, US Patent No. 5,630,981 ('981 patent), licensed to EOS was infringed by every Sinterstation and Vanguard system sold by DTM since August 1997, when EOS acquired the exclusive rights to all 3D Systems. patented laser-sintering technology.

In a counter-claim, 3D Systems asserted that certain nylon powders, which are currently sold by EOS in the U.S., infringe DTM's US Patent No. 5,990,268 (the '268 patent). However, the Court found that this patent contains multiple conflicting definitions of a key term of its claims and cannot be construed, therefore EOS cannot infringe this patent.

Are these rulings fair?

3D Systems doesn't believe they are, and plans to appeal.

"3D Systems is disappointed with the rulings but views this as one step in a long process," said G. Walter Loewenbaum II, Chairman of the Board of Directors. "3D Systems will appeal the rulings and believes that the law and the facts favor its position and will ultimately prevail, particularly given that these issues will be reviewed anew in the appellate court."

EOS GmbH, on the other hand, is hopeful that this will mark the end of the three-year battle.

"We are very pleased with these rulings," stated Dr. Hans J. Langer, founder and Chief Executive Officer of EOS. "The infringement ruling should be no surprise to 3D Systems, as it simply confirms what they told us in writing in 1997 when we were negotiating the license agreement. We find it very regrettable that having sold their laser-sintering rights exclusively to EOS, 3D Systems then decided not only to enter the laser-sintering market in breach of their agreements, but also to pursue legal action against EOS. With these new rulings it is very clear who is infringing who's patent rights. We hope that the whole litigation can now be ended quickly, and we are confident in our position."

Amy Rowell is the managing editor of
MCADCafe, and the editor of MCAD Weekly Review.

See also:
  • 3D Systems Announces Ruling in EOS vs. DTM/3D Systems Patent Lawsuit [21 Aug 2003]
  • Court Rules that 3D Systems Infringes EOS Patent Rights [26 Aug 2003]

    Top Stories
  • Court Rules that 3D Systems Infringes EOS Patent Rights [26 Aug 2003]
  • EDS Ships Unigraphics® NX 2 Providing Significant Enhancements In Knowledge Driven Product Development and Digital Simulation [28 Aug 2003]
  • IMSI® Signs Agreement to Acquire CADKEY [25 Aug 2003]
    Product and Company News
  • Altair Engineering Awarded U.S. Patent for New Ultra-Short Drive Shaft [27 Aug 2003]
  • Autodesk Offers New Data Vault for Autodesk Inventor Product Line [28 Aug 2003]
  • Cimatron Appoints New President & Chief Executive Officer [27 Aug 2003]
  • CIMdata Names OPEN MIND 2003 Market Leader [25 Aug 2003]
  • Fluent Releases Icepak 4.1 Electronics Cooling Design Software; Sets a New Standard for Speed [27 Aug 2003]
  • Informative Graphics Enables Microsoft SharePoint Software For Engineering -- CAD -- Content [27 Aug 2003]
  • Instant Verification! Vericut 5.3 launch button within EdgeCAM [28 Aug 2003]
  • Kline to Issue New Edition of High-Temperature Plastics Market Analysis [25 Aug 2003]
  • Matrox Parhelia™ meets stringent standards of new Autodesk® Inventor™ Certified Hardware Program [28 Aug 2003]
  • REI Releases Powerful Staad Structural Suite with New Foundation Design Program [26 Aug 2003]
  • think3 Selects Cincinnati for Worldwide Headquarters [26 Aug 2003]
    Special Notices
  • ANSYS to Present at SG Cowen 31st Annual Fall Technology Conference [28 Aug 2003]
  • Autodesk Inc. to Present at the Credit Suisse First Boston Global Software Conference [28 Aug 2003]
  • Autodesk Inc. to Present at the Smith Barney Citigroup 2003 Technology Conference [28 Aug 2003]
  • Delcam reseller SEACAM to host meetings for users and prospects [29 Aug 2003]
  • Gartner Selects Cyon Research as Event Partner for Midsize Enterprise Summit [28 Aug 2003]
  • Tim Murray Highlights the Following Stocks: Parametric Technology, Autodesk, Bank One, CompuCom, Grey Wolf, and Newell Rubbermaid [25 Aug 2003]
    Customer Wins
  • CFS Accelerates Food Production Machine Design With SolidWorks 3D Mechanical Design and COSMOS Analysis Software [27 Aug 2003]
  • Engineers at New York's Leading Companies Choose SolidWorks 3D Mechanical Design and Analysis Software [26 Aug 2003]
  • MSC.Software Professional Services Team Utilizes MSC.Marc to Design and Test Inflatable Dam [27 Aug 2003]
    more MCAD News]

    Recommended Reading

    (Note: $$ - denotes premium content. Article is available via a trial subscription or for a nominal fee.)

    By applying high-powered engineering, tiny Vectrix Corp. may have created a battery-powered scooter that can go head-to-head with gasoline-powered competitors on both range and acceleration.

    Design News, August 18, 2003

    A new ASME standard establishes requirements for preparing, organising and interpreting 3D digital product images.

    Design Engineering, August 20, 2003

    more Recommended Reading]


    The Emerging Technologies Conference 2003 September 24-25, 2003. Kresge Auditorium, MIT Campus, Cambridge, MA. The Emerging Technologies Conference at MIT will focus on the technologies that are poised to make a dramatic impact on our world.
    Technology Review Magazine, the authority on emerging technology, will bring together world-renowned innovators and key leaders in technology and business. The 2-day conference will feature a mixture of keynote, panel and breakout discussions that will center on the transformative technological innovations that have the potential to fuel new economic growth.

    PLM 2003 -- The Premier Lifecycle Management Event -- September 15-17, 2003, Scottsdale, AZ USA. PLM 2003 will take place September 16-17 in Scottsdale, AZ and is geared to executives in the entire spectrum and functional areas of product lifecycle management, with emphasis on lessons learned in the world's leading manufacturing organizations.

    PLM Road Map 2003 -- October 28-29, 2003, Dearborn, Mich USA. Join colleagues and share case histories on leading-edge implementations in Product Lifecycle Management. Topics covered include collaborative design, knowledge capture and reuse, collaborative CAE, high-integrity market-oriented product definition, physical architecture, manufacturing simulation, sourcing, product sales configuration, marketability, metrics and much more.

    more Events]

    You can find the full MCADCafe event calendar here.

    To read more news, click here.

    -- Amy Rowell, MCADCafe.com Contributing Editor.