[ Back ]   [ More News ]   [ Home ]
April 09, 2007
SolidWorks and Rhino Plug-In Connection
Please note that contributed articles, blog entries, and comments posted on MCADcafe.com are the views and opinion of the author and do not necessarily represent the views and opinions of the management and staff of Internet Business Systems and its subsidiary web-sites.
Jeff Rowe - Managing Editor

by Jeff Rowe - Contributing Editor
Each MCAD Weekly Review delivers to its readers news concerning the latest developments in the MCAD industry, MCAD product and company news, featured downloads, customer wins, and coming events, along with a selection of other articles that we feel you might find interesting. Brought to you by MCADCafe.com. If we miss a story or subject that you feel deserves to be included, or you just want to suggest a future topic, please contact us! Questions? Feedback? Click here. Thank you!

Lowell Walmsley, data exchange manager at McNeel, worked with Laurent Eraud, Datakit’s Rhino V3 plug-in specialist. Walmsley explained, “I don’t often travel for projects like this, but the time frame for the release of the final version was tight. Working side by side with Datakit to find solutions to the problems as they occurred helped us to progress very quickly.”

Datakit has been offering Rhinoceros V3 plug-ins for most CAD software for several years and has gained recognition within the Rhino community. Its products, which have capabilities for reading native formats, are distributed through a worldwide dealer network.

McNeel’s decision to integrate a SolidWorks converter based on the Datakit platform addressed a number of strategic and technical requirements.

Walmsley explains, “We entered into a partnership with SolidWorks to facilitate data exchange and interoperability between the two software products. We wanted to develop a solution that would read Rhino surfaces in SolidWorks, which we did, but then in order to provide more complete interoperability, we wanted to offer a solution that would read native SolidWorks files into Rhino V4. We knew about Datakit’s experience, and that’s why we contacted them to develop a Rhino V4 plug-in that would read SolidWorks geometry. Rhino has a great reputation for data exchange. We were looking for a tool that would be both fast and precise, would work like the other conversion
solutions we have in Rhino, and would deliver the seamless usability that matters a lot to our customers.”

Laurent Eraud, Datakit’s Rhino specialist, adds, “To be able to deliver 100% efficiency we found solutions for all the cases we encountered, including some that occur rarely but that could be a real obstacle for users; for example, when the SolidWorks model was originally imported and is flawed. Sharing an office enabled us to think things through together and look for solutions that would really address the way Rhino users work together in the real world.”

Lowell Walmsley looks back on the work accomplished at Datakit, “This was a satisfying experience on a technical level. The interface is up and running, it meets our expectations, and we have rolled it out on schedule. I have also learned about the way Datakit does things. The teamwork is great; everyone contributes his individual skills to the whole group.”

Commentary By Jeffrey Rowe, Editor

When you think of data translation/conversion products and services, Datakit has quite a bit of competition that makes it clear that what it and its competition provide are obviously in high demand. And, that demand shows absolutely no signs of abating anytime soon. As a matter of fact, data translation/conversion might even be considered a “growth industry” for the next several years as CAD data formats and related problems associated with them continue to proliferate.

Anyway, while this particular converter from McNeel’s Rhino to SolidWorks might be new, Datakit has worked extensively with McNeel in the past, and it already had plenty of ongoing partnerships with other CAD vendors, including Autodesk, Dassault Systemes, UGS, and the Open Design Alliance (the latter of which was involved with Autodesk’s trademark infringement lawsuit against it, but was ended last week as a federal judge approved a negotiated settlement between the two parties).

Datakit provides CAD data converters as either native and standard translators or plug-ins. Its technology allows 2D, 3D, wireframe, solid and surface data exchanges, as well as attributes, features, and history trees. All in all, Datakit has almost 130 data standalone and plug-in converters available.

As CAD products go, Rhino has been around a relatively long time and has quite a loyal following. I’ve evaluated and used it on and off for several years. In my mind, it’s always had five basic strengths going for it:

  • The right price – the current MSRP is under $1,000
  • Its surfacing capabilities and versatility
  • Its relatively modest hardware requirements
  • Its relatively short learning curve
  • Its ability to import and export data relatively cleanly
  • Rhino can create, edit, analyze, and translate NURBS curves, surfaces, and solids. There are no limits on complexity, degree, or size. Rhino also supports polygon meshes and point clouds. This all points to its capabilities and versatility.

    The new Rhino V4 plug-in that reads SolidWorks geometry is an additional step up for Rhino, an application that has had a well-deserved positive reputation for data exchange by itself.

    To me, what this points to (beyond the Rhino/Datakit/SolidWorks aspect of the announcement) is the increasing attention and importance that traditional MCAD vendors are placing on industrial design and the ability to handle complex, stylized surfaces. Software vendors’ customers are demanding these increasingly complex surface handling capabilities because their customers are demanding more organic and geometrically complex products.

    Many software developers are finally realizing that ID (industrial design) matters because it is increasingly becoming a product differentiator, especially for new technologies or those in crowded markets. The profession itself and the tools it uses continue to evolve right along with consumer product demand.

    CAD packages are not the same as CAID (computer-aided industrial design) packages, and vice versa: Each product type addresses a specific need and serves a definite purpose. Historically, CAID has occupied the conceptual front-end of the product-development process (primarily surfaces), while CAD has been best suited for the design refinement portion of the process (primarily solids).

    Traditionally, CAID packages were developed specifically with industrial designers in mind. In more of a graphical environment, they strive to stimulate creativity by providing a variety of design options. In essence, these tools are used to quickly create and alter the shape, form and surface qualities of 3D models. CAID tools also excel at presenting design concepts with photorealistic rendering and lighting effects. What they often lack is the degree of design precision found in most CAD tools, although this is changing fairly rapidly.

    Probably the biggest recent move in the industrial design tool market was Autodesk’s acquisition of Alias a couple of years ago. With the acquisition, Autodesk obtained new opportunities -- namely, a strong inroad to automotive styling and design and computer-aided industrial design through Alias' Studio Tools line. This broadened Autodesk's appeal on the conceptual side of the product-development cycle, where previously it was lacking. Studio Tools had long been known for its ability to create outstanding surfaces, and this capability is starting to come in handy when used in tandem with Autodesk's Inventor, an application that had never had a great reputation for

    complex surface creation. Over time, Alias and its products have been integrated into Autodesk's manufacturing suite (the product is now called Autodesk AliasStudio).

    For its part, SolidWorks for the past couple of years has eluded to the fact that it is also very interested in the industrial design market, and this new Rhino plug-in will help further that cause. Much like analysis, simulation, and visualization, ID is a part of the new MCAD frontier.

    The Week’s Top 5

    At MCADCafé we track many things, including the stories that have attracted the most interest from our subscribers. Below are the five news items that were the most viewed during last week.

    3D Helps Solve the Mystery of the Great Pyramid

    Dassault Systemes held a world premiere unveiling the scientifically proven Great Pyramid construction theory with its creator, architect Jean-Pierre Houdin, to model and explore the pyramid in 3D and run simulations confirming his theory that the pyramid was built from the inside. Dassault allowed Houdin to establish the first theory ever explaining the construction of the Great Pyramid from start to finish. The theory is founded on three foundations:

  • The use of an outside ramp to build the first 43 meters of the pyramid
  • The use of an internal spiral ramp running behind the faces of the pyramid to complete the construction
  • The use of the Great Gallery to accommodate an ingenious system of counterweights to lift the heavy granite ceiling rafters (up to 63 tons) in the King's Funeral Chamber.
  • The final step for Houdin and Dassault Systemes will be to prove the theory in real-life with non-invasive verification techniques conducted on the Great Pyramid’s site.

    Spaceclaim: A New Entrant In a Challenging Market.

    The MCAD market, valued at approximately $5 billion, is one of the oldest enterprise software markets and one of those rare big markets which has been kept in the hands of experts. Actually, Microsoft, IBM, SAP, and Oracle are not playing a strong role in the $12+ billion PLM market, leaving space for Dassault Systemes, Autodesk, PTC and UGS. This is most likely not going to change. Another challenge in targeting the extended enterprise is that several other vendors are already in that space with tools enabling the management, visualization and collaboration of the digital mock-up, DMU. Cimmetry and Adobe (Acrobat 3D) are among those who are successfully marketing their software to this
    same target. The question is: does this target need just visualization, collaboration and first level manipulation, or the more sophisticated functionalities that Spaceclaim offers? Spaceclaim has assets that include the experience and the track record of its founders and management, as co-founders of PTC. Will success repeat itself with Spaceclaim? That remains to be seen.

    Chengdu Aircraft and Dassault Systemes Take to the Skies with Composites

    Dassault Systemes announced that Chengdu Aircraft Industrial Group, a major Chinese supplier for the global aviation industry, is using Dassault's CATIA Composites Design to develop aircraft parts. Since composites are ultra lightweight and can be formed into any shape, they allow for inventive industrial design and provide Chengdu the means to meet aviation challenges with a competitive edge. Chengdu Aircraft is expanding its activities to cover the entire composites design process and provide customers with innovative design and manufacturing solutions. Capitalizing on its composites know-how, Chengdu is launching a Composites Manufacturing Research Center in partnership with Dassault
    Systemes that will be dedicated to investigating alternative manufacturing technologies.

    OPEN MIND hyperMILL in Solidworks

    The new CAD integration hyperMILL in SolidWorks allows CAM programs to be created with hyperMILL under the familiar user interface while a user is concurrently working within Solidworks. Both CAD and CAM access an identical database, thus working on a uniform data model throughout the entire process. hyperMILL in SolidWorks offers an array of strategies for 2D, 3D, HSC and 5-axis simultaneous machining. They allow an optimum machining of prismatic parts, making it suited for mechanical engineering. These include 2D cycles for face and contour milling, for milling various pocket geometries, as well as drilling and helical drilling. Roughing of any stock, 3D finishing, free path milling,
    ISO machining, automatic rest material machining, and multiple-job stock tracking offer numerous options for efficient 3D machining. A number of additional functions let more experienced users realize optimum machining quality and machining times.

    PTC Launches Product Development Process Framework That Links PLM to Business Objectives

    PTC announced a comprehensive process framework that consists of industry-specific product development process landscapes. The intent of this framework is to help discrete manufacturers in multiple industries understand the linkage between product development process improvements, PLM technology investments, and business value. Over the past 20 years, PTC has worked with leading product development companies in a variety of vertical industries to achieve a wide range of business goals. Subsequently, PTC has developed a tool based on this experience. Using the tool, PTC helps companies align and prioritize business and product development goals with industry-specific process
    improvements. The result is a rational technology adoption path that is tailored to each individual organization's objectives. The central communication vehicle for its process framework is the new PTC Value Roadmap – a configurable, interactive software application that matches an organization's goals with vertical industry best practices and delivers a dynamically created, customer-specific report. Currently, PTC has created seven industry/audience-specific process landscapes with plans for two additional in the coming months. Each of the 7 process landscape incorporates between 11 and 24 critical product development processes.

    Jeffrey Rowe is the editor of
    MCADCafé and MCAD Weekly Review. He can be reached at
    Email Contact or 408.850.9230.

    This Week

    Lead Story

  • Converter between SolidWorks & Rhino 4.0Product and Company News

  • UGS Delivers Three Millionth Teamcenter License in 2006
  • GM Names UGS Supplier of the Year
  • Autodesk Surpasses 8M Licensed Users
  • KOMPAS-3D Introduces Model Recognition Add-On
  • SpaceClaim Announces Availability of SpaceClaim Professional 2007
  • Avatech Enters Autodesk Platinum Club
  • Airplane Parts Manufacturer Manages Critical Documents
  • Rwanda To Launch CAD File Conversion Company with Help From SolidWorks
  • ALGOR V20 Provides New Modeling Environment for CAD and FEA
  • KOMPAS-3D Users Create Parametric 2D/3D Libraries With New Template Manager
  • POLYFLOW 3.11 Extends Its Complex Physics
  • Synergis EDS to Help with Autodesk 2008 Products Move
  • MSC.Software Announces Worldwide Channel Summits
  • OPEN MIND Has Success with F1 Team
  • UGS Certified As 5-Star Vendor by Magazine
  • Claiming Space in the MCAD Market
  • Cimmetry and LDSI Sign New ISV Agreement
  • Agile Announces Agile 9.2 Release
  • Autodesk Recognizes Top-Selling Channel Partners
  • CD-adapco Article: Simulation of Vehicle Soiling at Audi
  • Results Drive CoCreate Software to Expand European Channel
  • OPEN MIND Participates in Zero-Stock Machining Workshop at Emuge
  • FISHER/UNITECH and Configure One Form Strategic Partnership
  • Renishaw Funds Delcam
  • Bianchi Relies on think3 for Bicycle Market
  • ALGOR V20 Wins Readers' Choice Award
  • Proficiency Partners with INCAT For CAD Interoperability
  • Cimatron Opens New Offices
  • Delcam Sets Sales Record in 2006
  • Machinist Gets a CAD Education the Easy Way
  • Delcam to Show Automated Blisk and Impellor Programming
  • Catalog Data Solutions Adopted by Advanced Machine EngineeringRelated MCAD News

  • Dell Will Delay Form 10-K Filing Pending Investigation
  • Cincom Named One of Most Influential Manufacturing Technology Providers
  • Boeing Unveils Improved Access Features on the 787
  • Automotive X Prize Announces Guidelines for Super-Efficient Vehicles
  • Synova Teams with Kataoka to Manufacture Laser MicroJet Tools
  • High School Students Recognized at Regional Robotics Competition
  • Texas Manufacturing Activity Continues to Expand in March
  • Gain Insight in to the Electromedical and Electrotherapeutic Apparatus Manufacturing Industry
  • CyberShift Selected to List of Most Influential Manufacturing Technology Providers
  • Boeing Prepares Fuel Cell Demonstrator Airplane for Testing
  • Spire and KUKA to Provide Robotic Photovoltaic Manufacturing Lines
  • CSEM Demos Miniature Vision Sensor System at SAE World Congress
  • Visiprise Announces Visiprise Manufacturing 4.3
  • U.S. Congressman Honored for Votes on Key Manufacturing Issues
  • The Inductor Manufacturing Industries 2006 Revenue Over $1.25BCorporate Moves

  • MSC.Software Appoints New CFOIndustry Events

  • ESI Group Announces Free CFD Seminar
  • Delcam to Show PartMaker at PMTS
  • ASCON to Exhibit at Hannover Messe 2007

    You can find the full MCADCafe event calendar here.

    To read more news, click here.

    -- Jeff Rowe, MCADCafe.com Contributing Editor.