[ Back ]   [ More News ]   [ Home ]
January 23, 2012
Hardware Review: 3DBOXX 3970 XTREME Workstation
Please note that contributed articles, blog entries, and comments posted on MCADcafe.com are the views and opinion of the author and do not necessarily represent the views and opinions of the management and staff of Internet Business Systems and its subsidiary web-sites.
Jeff Rowe - Managing Editor


by Jeff Rowe - Contributing Editor
Each MCAD Weekly Review delivers to its readers news concerning the latest developments in the MCAD industry, MCAD product and company news, featured downloads, customer wins, and coming events, along with a selection of other articles that we feel you might find interesting. Brought to you by MCADCafe.com. If we miss a story or subject that you feel deserves to be included, or you just want to suggest a future topic, please contact us! Questions? Feedback? Click here. Thank you!


Although generalized, so-called consumer-grade computers have made huge strides forward in terms of performance, some users still need some extra computing horsepower based on the applications they run and the work they perform. In other words, not all computer users need an engineering workstation-class machine, but many still truly do, especially with graphics- and computational-intensive applications, such as Inventor, Alias Design, and 3ds Max. While some relatively high-powered workstations usually come with a price premium, you actually can pay a relatively small price for higher levels of performance, and it is usually
worth it. One of the most notable, compelling, and economical premium computers that I've encountered in a number of years is the 3DBOXX 3970 XTREME desktop workstation that offers rock solid build quality and amazing performance for the price.

 


The 3DBOXX 3970 XTREME has high levels of performance, as well as design and build quality.

Just about every engineering and manufacturing company today has a couple users who need a little extra computing horsepower than is available in a generic desktop computer where a standard desktop PC might be perfectly suitable. However, heavy graphics and especially 3D can tax a standard PC fine beyond its limitations. For these types of applications and users, seriously consider a workstation. Even in 2011, workstations aren’t a major requirement for everyone. But, if you need a powerful PC to work with graphics and 3D tasks, and willing to pay a bit extra for optimized hardware for these

types of tasks, the 3DBOXX 3970 XTREME deserves a serious look.


Justifying A True Engineering Workstation


Not all that long ago, the decision of to go with a consumer-oriented PC versus an engineering workstation was easy – either you could afford the latter or you couldn't.

Today, however, the price differential is actually quite small for what you are likely to get in terms of increased performance. The single most expensive component of any workstation is the graphics card, and you can spend a lot of money on one, if you need it. However, for the majority of MCAD users, the graphics cards offered as standard equipment on most true engineering workstations are more than adequate for modeling and rendering purposes. This was certainly the case with the NVIDIA Quadro 4000 with 2GB memory that came with the 3DBOXX 3970 XTREME review machine. It performed quite well and never bogged down with
anything we subjected it to, including some animations and multi-physics simulations.

The bottom line is that today you don't really pay much of a premium for a true engineering workstation compared with a generic consumer box, so is definitely worth considering. In fact, I've found that the price/performance ratio really favors the engineering workstation.

A Look Inside the 3DBOXX 3970 XTREME

From the outside, you'll immediately notice the distinct appearance of the 3970. It looks solid with a real serious “engineering” look that means business. The exterior case is completely fabricated from metal – a nice departure from the flimsy plastic cases enclosing many other computers these days.

The interior of the computer is very easy to access. Just unscrew two thumb screws on either side of the case and you're in. No tools required.

Once inside, you'll notice the clean layout and routing of wires and cables. You'll also notice the massive heat sinks on the motherboard and graphics card, as well as three relatively quiet air cooling fans located on the front (one fan) and back (two fans) of the case for efficient cooling. Speaking of cooling, the 3970 is also liquid cooled using an Asetek system for keeping the overclocked CPU cool. All in all, very cool – no pun intended. The only thing I question is whether running the CPU on a constant overclocked basis could be detrimental to the life of the CPU – I guess only time would tell.

A response from the manufacturer on our overclocking concern: “BOXX has been shipping overclocked systems since 2008 and throughout these past four years, we have not experienced a processor failure rate any different from that of standard processor systems. This is because we work closely with our partner (Intel) to ensure that we stay within the parameters of safe overclocking, providing increased performance without applying significantly larger increases in voltage. All BOXX workstations (whether they be overclocked, liquid-cooled XTREME editions or our standard 3DBOXX models) are backed by the same three
year warranty.”

The review machine came with a 7200-rpm, 1TB SATA drive which was fast, but the real bonus for performance was the Intel 20 GB cache solid state drive (SSD). Although still a bit pricey at present, the SSD provides noticeable improvements in data retrieval, and just one of the many reasons the 3970 has such high levels of performance. The SSD also provides higher levels of reliability. The 3970 incorporates Intel’s Smart Response and Rapid Storage Technology that combines responsiveness similar to a high-performance SSD with the capacity and relative low-cost of a hard drive. The two technologies (SSD and HDD) appear as
a single C:\ drive in the3970.

Measuring Performance

When we received the 3970 XTREME, we had high expectations for performance. The objective and subjective tests we ran confirmed and satisfied our expectations. Keep in mind that the tests were performed with the machine in an “out of the box” state, nothing was tweaked or optimized to skew performance. I actually get more out of the subjective testing because it's more “real world,” but the raw numbers from the benchmarks are also useful, as well as a means of comparison. Your mileage on these evaluations may differ from mine, but they do provide a point for comparison.

For objective testing, we ran two benchmarks NovaBench (geared more toward overall performance) and SPECviewperf 11 (geared more toward graphics performance).

NovaBench Benchmark Test:

8168 MB System RAM (Score: 225)

-.RAM Speed: 17,805 MB/s

CPU Tests (Score: 887

- Floating Point Operations/Second: 207,582,872

- Integer Operations/Second: 1,075,200,168

- MD5 Hashes Generated/Second: 1,504,527

Graphics Tests (Score: 345)

- 3D Frames Per Second: 976

Hardware Tests (Score: 75)

- Primary Partition Capacity: 931 GB

- Drive Write Speed: 203 MB/s

Total NovaBench Composite Score: 1,532

The 1,532 composite score is especially impressive because the average score of other workstations in this class was 708. So, the 3970 XTREME provided more than double the performance in relative terms.

SPECviewperf 11 Benchmark Test:

The scores for the various tests (CATIA, Solidworks, Lightwave, Ensight, NX, and Pro/ENGINEER) are the best I have ever personally encountered and averaged approximately 30% better than any other desktop workstation I have benchmarked and reviewed.

For subjective testing, I ran Autodesk Alias Design, Inventor, Simulation, and 3ds Max. I used a data set of standard models that I have created over the years for this testing, including a model with 50,000+ parts, renderings of complex surfaces, advanced FEA, and animations. The 3970 XTREME's performance did not bog down with whatever I threw at it. I could have run software from other vendors and suspect I would have experienced similar levels of performance, but chose to use only the Autodesk design suite in the interest of time.

Final Thoughts

If you need a lot of computational horsepower and are willing to spend just a little more for a true engineering workstation, then the 3DBOXX 3970 XTREME is definitely worth your consideration. The relatively small price premium you pay for a machine of this build quality and performance are well worth the price of admission. If you deal with large models or intricate renderings, this is the machine for you.

On many levels this machine is a monster, and I mean that in a good way. Regardless of price, it's been a long time since I experienced a desktop engineering workstation of this caliber and quality. I highly recommend it because justifying its purchase is a no-brainer.



 

3DBOXX 3970 XTREME Series Desktop Workstation Configuration (As Reviewed)
  • CPU: Intel i7 Quad Core Enhanced Performance 4.5 GHz
  • RAM: 8GB DDR
  • Video Card: NVIDIA Quadro 4000 with 2GB memory
  • Hard Drives: 20 GB SSD cache hard drive; 1TB SATA
  • 20X dual layer DVD+/-RW Writer
  • Microsoft Windows 7 Professional Edition 64-bit

  • Pluses: Build quality; expandability; all aspects of performance; support

    Minuses: None experienced – a rarity.

    Price (as supplied): $4,102.00

    Overall Grade:A+

    Contact: 877-877-BOXX (2699);


    The Week’s Top 5


    At MCADCafé we track many things, including the stories that have attracted the most interest from our subscribers. Below are the five news items that were the most viewed during last week.



    Hyundai Motor Company and Kia Motors Corporation Completes First Phase of PTC PLM System Deployment PTC announced it has completed the first phase of deployment of its enterprise product lifecycle management (PLM) system at Hyundai Motor Co. and Kia Motors Corp. (HMC/KMC). The combined companies represent the fourth largest, and fastest growing, automobile manufacturer in the world. HMC/KMC selected PTC's Windchill as its enterprise PLM solution in early 2011. PTC’s Windchill
    consolidates multiple existing systems into a single platform for managing critical product data and related processes for vehicle development. PTC’s Windchill is being deployed within HMC/KMC’s core research and development groups to establish a system of record for the complete vehicle, which will include design data from a range of different systems including CATIA and Pro/ENGINEER (now Creo Parametric). In addition, Windchill will also help handle the complexity caused by the increasing number of vehicle change management requests and, further, will provide a comprehensive Digital Mock-Up (DMU) environment.



    Gstarsoft has built PDF2DXF functionality into an integrated add-on to GstarCAD2012 called PDFtoDXF. This function significantly expands the scope of the applicability by enabling users to convert Adobe PDF format drawings directly into .dxf in GstarCAD2012. PDF2DXF is a function developed by Visual Integrity for users who frequently need to convert PDF-based vector CAD drawings into .dxf format, which can be opened as well as edited in GstarCAD2012. Once opened in GstarCAD2012, the .dxf file can be easily saved as .dwg format file.



    ETRAGE LLC announced the availability of the Etrage Integration Server (EIS) for PTC’s Windchill PDMLink and Pro/ INTRALINK and the IFS Applications suite.EIS is a flexible, modular data transfer infrastructure that can integrate heterogeneous engineering, manufacturing and business systems from different vendors, such as CAD, PDM, PLM, ERP, and MRP systems for a robust, bidirectional exchange of data between these systems.Etrage’s integration of IFS Applications with PTC’s Windchill PDMLink and Pro/ INTRALINK, using EIS provides, real-time updates of Bills of Materials (BOM) changes into IFS Applications, streamlines data flow between the engineering, manufacturing
    and purchasing departments, eliminates manual data entry or processes of large sets of data and insures that manufacturing and purchasing has access to the most up to date BOM and drawings inside IFS Applications.



    Theorem Solutions announced its DGN to CATIA V5 CADverter, developed to bridge the gap between plant design and mechanical CAD, resolving issues with incompatible data formats and the ability to complete full design reviews of combined data sets when these two design paths meet.The Microstation (DGN) to CATIA V5 CADverter has been designed specifically to take data from Microstation into CATIA V5 and Delmia. It enables CATIA and Delmia users to take Microstation shared cell instances or reference files which are used to define product structure and create CATproducts in CATIA V5 or Delmia. Then, by taking individual Microstation geometric items and creating a CATpart or CGR
    representation it creates geometric representations for use in CATIA V5 or Delmia.



    Maplesoft announced the latest version of its testing and assessment tools. Maple T.A. was first released as a pilot project in 2002. Ten years later, Maple T.A. and the Maple T.A. MAA Placement Test Suite continue the tradition of providing major advancements to help institutions offer high quality technical education. Adaptive questions in Maple T.A. 8 give instructors a powerful new tool to improve student comprehension. These questions give extra guidance to students who give an incorrect response to a question, increasing their understanding of the concepts and techniques involved. Knowing the student is having trouble, the question can be adapted to walk the student through the
    problem one step at a time, allow students to try a simpler version of the same question before retrying the original, or whatever the instructor feels is appropriate. As a result, adaptive questions give students the opportunity to deepen their understanding without leaving the testing environment, while at the same time giving them partial credit for their efforts.


    Jeffrey Rowe is the editor of
    MCADCafé and MCAD Weekly Review. He can be reached at
    Email Contact or 719.221.1867.




    This Week



    Product and Company News


























































    Related MCAD News












    Corporate Moves






    Industry Events




















    Corporate Newsletters



    You can find the full MCADCafe event calendar here.


    To read more news, click here.



    -- Jeff Rowe, MCADCafe.com Contributing Editor.