The True Value of Design Automation

You get a lot of varied reactions when you mention the word “automation” to people. Some people fear for their jobs, envisioning some robot working faster and smarter than they do. Some people see their inherently flawed process just producing more crap faster. Some people see salespeople putting garbage into the system expecting magic to come out the other side. The commonality is that people see a black box that magically turns specifications into designs instantly. A good automation program actually isn’t all that far off from the black box, but the fears that people have about the box are actually the benefits of the automation tools.

The first fear that people have is being replaced by a machine. Well let’s face it folks, in a lot of Engineer-To-Order (ETO) and Configure-To-Order (CTO) companies, we ARE machines. We take sales information and spit out quotes all day. I don’t know about you, but I didn’t barely make it through Thermodynamics so that I could just plug and chug numbers all day. Automating the non-value added tasks, like some pre-sales work, frees the engineers up to do what we were meant to do, tough engineering validations and more importantly, New Product Development (NPD). Handling incoming sales volume is important to bringing in money, but developing new products to tap into new markets brings in a lot more money for the company.

The next thing that people say is that they’re process is too tough to automate. Nothing can be done automatically because so much of it is manual. While it’s true that you can’t automate everything, the reality is that the process of adopting automation forces you to re-evaluate your process. Your current process is probably 30 years old or more. It’s been tweaked a bit along the way, but it can’t possibly take into account the latest 3D technology or the tools that are available for design automation. You can’t just automate a process. You can’t just apply technology to a process. You need to make the technology and the process flexible enough to create a new, automated process.

Another big problem today, that people feel will halt any efforts to automate, is that the salespeople that collect the information rarely get all of the information required to quote a job. In some companies, every quote request is followed by a call to the customer to get more information. Automation can solve this by requiring all of the information before a salesperson can request a quote. Automation tools today, and even VB.NET and Excel can be used to create user interfaces that help salespeople get complete and accurate information.

The information is accurate because automation tools have a benefit beyond automation. They generally do validation as well. This means that the rules that are put in to automate are also used to make sure that the design is possible. This would mean the end to salespeople selling things that cannot be manufactured.

But automation isn’t for everyone. Some tasks require the art of the engineer. Some processes can only be partially automated, some completely automated, and some not at all. But the most important thing to remember is that the technology is new and you don’t know what it can do to your process. If you’re convinced that the way that you’re doing things now is the ultimate way, don’t automate. If you have an open mind, and are willing to accommodate technology and willing to bend technology to meet you halfway, then go for it.

BY: Paul Gimbel
Email Contact

Review Article
  • Design Automation provides real competitive advantages. March 21, 2006
    Reviewed by 'Ulf'
    We at Design Power believe that design automation is absolutely crucial for the competitiveness of any manufacturing and engineering organization that custom-engineers systems and products to order. And it is true for the nation as well. The fears that Paul alludes to are very shortsighted. Only automation can increase the productivity to a level where jobs can be retained on-shore. A prime example is the design automation at a metal building manufacturing company, Robertson Ceco Corporation [RCC]. While engineering and detailing has been off-shored to a high degree by most of their competition RCC has retained all of their engineering and detailing on-shore.

    The RCC solution was described in a recent AECbytes newsletter article:

    NCI of Houston, TX, another metal building and building products company for a very good price recently announced a definitive agreement to acquire RCC. In a webcast following the announcement NCI praised the design automation as one of the key assets that they acquired. Eventually the combined NCI and RCC organization will annually engineer and detail 15,000 buildings in a highly automated fashion.

    Ulf Strom
    Design Power, Inc.

      One person of 4 found this review helpful.

      Was this review helpful to you?   (Report this review as inappropriate)

  • As a KBE consulting firm we have lived a long time in Paul's Article March 15, 2006
    Reviewed by 'Terry Davis'
    Paul has clearly and succinctly identified the fears and trepidations that the engineers and these companies feel. Some of what the engineers do is "just work" and they would love to shed this repetitive aspect of their job and do real engineering work.

    The nature of the market is driving companies who have traditionally built only catalog products into this space defined by customer demand.

    DAA has been building successful custom Knowledge Based Engineering applicaitons for over a decade. All of our customers fit in the Engineer to Order, Design-to-Order or Customs & Specials market space. All of our prospects and customers, at some point, intimate to us all of the aspects brought forth in Paul's article.

    Great Job Paul!

      6 of 9 found this review helpful.
      Was this review helpful to you?   (Report this review as inappropriate)

For more discussions, follow this link …

SolidCAM - Break The Chains

Featured Video
Mid-Level Mechanical Engineer for Kiewit at lenexa, Kansas
Mechanical Engineer for Allen & Shariff Corporation at Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
System Designer/Engineer for Bluewater at Southfield, Michigan
Software Developer for CHA Consulting, Inc. at Norwell, Massachusetts
Product Manager for CHA Consulting, Inc. at Boston, Massachusetts
Geospatial Analyst/Programmer for LANDIQ at Sacramento, California
Upcoming Events
Live SOLIDWORKS Event Hosted by Converge at 2482 Patterson Rd Unit 2 Grand Junction CO - May 22, 2018
ESPRIT World 2018 at Indianapolis Marriott Downtown 350 West Maryland Street Indianapolis IN - Jun 11 - 15, 2018
HxGN LIVE 2018 at The Venetian Las Vegas NV - Jun 12 - 15, 2018
IMTS2018 International Manufacturing Tech Show at McCormick Place Chicago IL - Sep 10 - 15, 2018
Kenesto: 30 day trial
SolidCAM: Break the Chains

Internet Business Systems © 2018 Internet Business Systems, Inc.
25 North 14th Steet, Suite 710, San Jose, CA 95112
+1 (408) 882-6554 — Contact Us, or visit our other sites:
AECCafe - Architectural Design and Engineering EDACafe - Electronic Design Automation GISCafe - Geographical Information Services TechJobsCafe - Technical Jobs and Resumes ShareCG - Share Computer Graphic (CG) Animation, 3D Art and 3D Models
  Privacy PolicyAdvertise