Software Review: Photoshop CS4 Extended For Engineering Imaging
[ Back ]   [ More News ]   [ Home ]
Software Review: Photoshop CS4 Extended For Engineering Imaging

OK, I’ll admit it up front; I’m a big fan of Photoshop and have been for quite some time. Is it perfect? No. Can its features get complicated to understand and use? Yes. Is it well-suite for “creative types?” Also, yes. Does it also have a place in the technical arena and the engineer’s toolbox? Increasingly, yes. In fact, I find it to be one of the more useful technical/engineering applications, especially coupled with a CAD product, but more about that later.

Instead of trying to cover the myriad features and capabilities of Photoshop CS4, the newest version, we’ll stick to applications of interest to engineers, namely, analysis, measurement, and using a photographic image as the basis for a design using a CAD product. In other words, this evaluation will only entail engineering imaging with Photoshop CS4.

This software review was conducted on a Lenovo ThinkPad W700ds loaner. This is a very interesting machine that actually is well-suited for a graphics product such as Photoshop because it has two beautiful and bright screens (a 17” main screen and a supplemental 10” screen that slides out of the main screen); a digital graphics pad; and hueyPRO monitor color correction. It had an Intel Core 2 Extreme CPU Q9300 running at 2.53 GHz, 4GB RAM, and 64-bit Windows Vista Business. All in all, a hardware platform optimized for this application.

As I said earlier, I’ve used Photoshop for several years, but have experience using it for engineering imaging applications only a little over a year, beginning with Photoshop CS3 Extended. However, I have really grown to appreciate what can be done with it on a more “technical” side, as well as its usefulness on the more “creative” side.

I think some of the most compelling capabilities for engineers are the 2D and 3D measurement tools in Photoshop CS4 Extended. This tool set lets you extract real quantitative information from digital photographic images or drawings.

In Photoshop Extended, you can also measure the dimensions of a photograph or a digital model (2D or 3D) using the measurement feature. You begin by assigning a known measurement to any part of an image or model, then you can take other accurate measurements. For example, you can import a photo of an object, enter a known dimension from the photo, such as the width of a slot, and then generate measurements of any other feature of the object, such as its height, width, depth, distance apart, etc.

Using the measurement feature in Photoshop Extended you can measure any area defined with the Ruler tool or with a selection tool, including irregular areas selected with the lasso, quick select, or magic wand tools. You can also compute the height, width, area, and perimeter, or track measurements of one image or multiple images. It’s best to choose a measurement tool that matches the kind of data you want to record in the Measurement Log that keeps track of data including width, height, area, units, scale, and file name. You can customize the Measurement Log columns, as well as sort data within columns, and export data from the log to a text file or spreadsheet.

Setting a measurement scale sets a specified number of pixels in the image equal to a number of scale units, such as inches or millimeters. Once you’ve created a scale, you can measure areas and receive calculations and log results in the selected scale units. You can create multiple measurement scale presets for frequently used measurement scales, although only one scale can be used in a document at a time.

To ensure that I was accurate from the beginning for my first experience with the measurement feature, I set my measurement scale using a digital macro photo of a 100-mm machinist’s scale. This absolutely ensured that I had known dimensions. I discovered that the higher the resolution of the photograph, the higher the accuracy of the measurement, as I experimented with photos of different resolutions.

Once the measurement scale is established, you can draw lines with the Ruler tool to measure linear distance and angle. Each measurement measures one or more data points. The data points you select determine the information recorded in the Measurement log. Data points correspond to the type of tool you’re measuring with. Area, perimeter, height, and width are available data points for measuring selections. You can create and save sets of data points for particular types of measurements to speed the process. The steps for performing the process are pretty simple:

  1. Open a photograph or model document.
  2. Select Analysis>Set Measurement Scale and choose a measurement scale preset for the document or choose Custom and set a custom measurement scale. Measurements are computed and recorded in the Measurement Log using the scale units in effect when a measurement is recorded. If no measurement scale is defined, the default scale is 1 pixel = 1 pixel.
  3. In the Select Data Points dialog box, data points are grouped according to the measurement tool that can measure them, and add useful information to the Measurement Log, such as the name of the file being measured, the measurement scale, and the date/time of the measurement. By default all data points are selected. You can select a subset of data points for a particular kind of measurement and save the combination to make it available as a data point preset.
  4. Choose an image feature and measurement tool to match the selected data points, and either create one or more selections on the image, or choose Analysis > Ruler Tool, or click the Ruler tool in the toolbox, then use the tool to measure the length of an image area.
  5. Open the Measurement Log palette to examine and export your measurement data to Excel or database package for documentation or analysis.

Setting a measurement scale sets a specified number of pixels in the image equal to a number of scale units, such as inches, millimeters, or microns. Once you’ve created a scale, you can measure areas and receive calculations and log results in the selected scale units. You can create multiple measurement scale presets, although only one scale can be used in a document at a time.

You can place scale markers on an image to display the measurement scale. Scale markers can appear with or without a caption displaying measurement scale units.

Use the Ruler tool to set the measurement scale for a document. You can create measurement scale presets for frequently used measurement scales. Presets are added to the Analysis>Set Measurement Scale submenu. The current measurement scale for a document is checked in the submenu, and appears in the Info panel. Measurement scale markers display the measurement scale used in your document. Set the measurement scale for a document before creating a scale marker.

You can measure using the Photoshop selection tools, Ruler tool, or Count tool. You should choose a measurement tool that matches the type of data you want to record in the Measurement Log.

Each measurement measures one or more data points. The data points you select determine the information recorded in the Measurement log. Data points correspond to the type of tool you’re measuring with. Area, perimeter, height, and width are available data points for measuring selections. Length and angle are available data points for Ruler tool measurements. You can create and save sets of data points for particular types of measurements to speed your workflow. If your currently selected data points do not correspond to the current measurement tool, you are asked to select data points for that tool.

The Measurement log has columns for each data point you selected in the Measurement Data Points dialog box. Each measurement you make enters a new row of data in the Measurement Log.

If you measure multiple selected areas on an image, one row of data is created in the log containing summary or cumulative data for all selected areas, followed by a row of data for each selection area. Each selection area is listed as a separate Feature in the Label column of the log and assigned a unique number.

Photoshop CS4 Extended Evaluation Quick Guide*
Overall Product: A-
This version: A-
Ease of use: B+
Features: A-
Documentation: B
Innovation: A-
Value: A-
Price: Pricing for Photoshop CS4 Extended is $999.00 to purchase and $349.00 to upgrade from Photoshop CS3 Extended
For More Information: http://www.adobe.com/products/photoshop/photoshopextended/

Editor’s Note: The Evaluation Quick Guide is based only on the engineering imaging features and capabilities of Photoshop CS4 Extended.

For more advanced analytic engineering work, and although I haven’t tried this yet, I understand that it is possible for Photoshop CS4 Extended to export to and import data from MATLAB (a technical computing environment and programming language for visualizing data) and visualize the results of MATLAB algorithms. With Photoshop Extended, MATLAB can be used to view the results of algorithms created in MATLAB from within Photoshop, as well as export images created and/or edited in Photoshop back out to MATLAB for detailed analysis.

I could envision the measurement tools in Photoshop CS4 Extended being used for fairly sophisticated purposes ranging from inspection to reverse engineering. As engineering-oriented features and capabilities such as the measurement tools continue to evolve in Photoshop, expect to see it on more engineers’ workstations because of its possibilities.

If you have any specific questions pertaining to Photoshop CS4 Extended that were not addressed in this short review, feel free to contact me at Email Contact


The Week’s Top 5

At MCADCafé we track many things, including the stories that have attracted the most interest from our subscribers. Below are the five news items that were the most viewed during last week.

Procter & Gamble Selects Dassault Systèmes as Enterprise Simulation Partner
Dassault Systèmes announced that Procter & Gamble Company (P&G), the world’s largest consumer goods company, has selected SIMULIA SLM as its simulation lifecycle management solution to support P&G’s modeling & simulation strategy. The announcement evolves the long-standing business relationship in the simulation domain from one of solution provider into a strategic, collaborative partnership. By working closely with SIMULIA, P&G will define critical SLM requirements and identify out-of-the-box capabilities that will be incorporated into the general SIMULIA SLM solution and adopted globally within P&G. Based on Dassault Systèmes’ V6 platform, the online collaborative environment for PLM 2.0, SIMULIA SLM enables P&G to capture, share and automate the execution of approved simulation methods, improve traceability of simulation data, and accelerate decision-making while securing valuable intellectual property. By integrating its existing systems with ENOVIA’s Consumer Packaged Goods (CPG) Accelerator for Global Specification Management, P&G will be able to better manage products spanning multiple brands and markets.

PlanetSolar Taps Autodesk Digital Prototyping Software for First Solar-Powered Round-the-World Voyage
Autodesk is sponsoring a unique project from PlanetSolar to produce the world's largest solar-powered sailboat capable of circumnavigating the globe. Based in Germany, PlanetSolar is leading the project to construct the solar catamaran, and Autodesk is supplying the digital prototyping technology and training that will help PlanetSolar design and build it. Autodesk supplied PlanetSolar engineers with digital prototyping software from the Autodesk Inventor and Autodesk Alias product families along with AutoCAD Electrical and Autodesk Productstream to help PlanetSolar digitally design, visualize and simulate the solar catamaran before it is built. The project is the brainchild of Raphael Domjan, president of PlanetSolar, who will also pilot the boat. The Knierim Yachtbau in Kiel, Germany, will assemble the boat. The first solar-powered circumnavigation of the globe is planned for 2010 along the equatorial route. The voyage - which will cover nearly 25,000 miles (more than 40,000 kilometers) at an average speed of 10 knots -- is expected to take about 120 days and set several new world records. Stops are planned in major harbors where the capabilities of renewable energies and solar power will be on display to a wider audience. For more information, visit www.planetsolar.org.

Anark Releases Anark Core 2.2
Anark Corp. announced the release of the Anark Core Platform 2.2. This new release supports direct export of the Autodesk DWG format. The Anark Core platform is a software platform that transforms native 3D CAD data for use throughout manufacturing, design, engineering, and support organizations. Unlike conventional CAD tools and translators, Anark Core enables users to automate the modification of 3D product structure and geometry, and export revised product data into high-precision B-rep and lightweight mesh formats. The addition of 3D DWG support enables users to quickly and easily convert and simplify their 3D CAD geometry for use in visualization products such as Autodesk Revit, Bentley MicroStation, Google SketchUp, 20-20 Technologies Cap Studio, and others. Anark Core's powerful automation capabilities, coupled with support for 3D mechanical and AEC CAD formats, enable manufacturers to exponentially reduce costs by automating the production of optimized lightweight DWG models for use in layout, space planning, configuration, and catalog applications. Additionally, Anark Core 2.2 includes numerous new features and performance enhancements, including a new feature called “Region Select” that reduces the time to create shell geometry for visualization and simulation applications as well as supply chain data exchange and collaboration. The company also added direct export support for MultiGen-Paradigm's OpenFlight format, the visual database format for simulation and visualization applications.

VISTAGY Introduces SyncroFIT
VISTAGY Inc.announced that its product line of software for developing airframe assemblies —comprised of Airframe Design Environment and Airframe Manufacturing Environment—has been changed to SyncroFIT to enhance its brand recognition in the rapidly expanding airframe assembly market. SyncroFIT, previously known as Airframe Development Environments, is a group of software products integrated into commercial 3D CAD systems for designing and manufacturing airframe assemblies and large aerostructures. SyncroFIT enables the user to easily author and capture complete digital representations of airframe assemblies and share critical design and manufacturing detail more efficiently across the enterprise and the global supply chain. The software provides a thorough representation of the airframe assembly, including individual mating parts and their relationships to joints, fasteners and holes. It also manages the interactions of composite details within assemblies and allows engineers to validate that fastener design rules have been met.

PROSTEP Partners with Siemens PLM Software
Darmstadt-headquartered PROSTEP AG, Germany’s leading specialist for product data and process integration, has signed a Partner agreement with Siemens PLM Software. As a Software and Technology partner, PROSTEP will provide integrations with PDM and CAD software tools from Siemens PLM Software. PROSTEP extends the existing capability of its OpenDXM and OpenPDM products to allow additional automation, workflow, and standards based interoperability between a variety of third-party and in house applications. This includes internal integrations within a company as well as the integration of external partners, suppliers and customers. PROSTEP AG is recognized as the leading PLM integration specialist in the area of product data integration. The company offers customers from the aerospace, automotive, shipbuilding and mechanical engineering industries – including EADS/AIRBUS, BMW, Volkswagen, Daimler – integration solutions for CAD, PDM and supplier communication, thus making e-engineering a reality.

Jeffrey Rowe is the editor of MCADCafé and MCAD Weekly Review. He can be reached at Email Contact or 408.850.9230.


This Week

Lead Story

Software Review: Photoshop CS4 Extended For Engineering Imaging


Product and Company News

New Inspection and Reverse Engineering Tool Integrated into SolidWorks 2009 from ReverseEngineering.com

Mindray Delivers Award Winning Medical Devices Designed with Pro/ENGINEER and Pro/INTRALINK

Autodesk 2010 Design and Engineering Software Product Line Now Available

SpaceClaim Secures $7 Million in New Funding

Coastal Logic Partners with Dassault Systèmes

New AutoCAD 2010 and Autodesk 2010 Product Documentation Available for Download

TopSolid’Cam 2009 Launched

VISTAGY Introduces FiberSIM 2009

IMSI/Design Matches AutoCAD LT 2010 Upgrade Pricing and Offers Free Product

Blue Ridge Numerics Introduces CFdesign V10 for Autodesk Inventor 2010

TransMagic R8 Certified for Autodesk Inventor 2010

Autodesk Inventor Helps Designers Focus on World's Largest Telescope

New CFdesign UVCalc Module Removes Barriers for Design Engineers to Validate Reactor Performance for UV Light Disinfection

ANSYS Expands HPC Capacity for Enhanced R&D

Autodesk Launches Online Site to For Millions of AutoCAD Users to Interact and Learn from Each Other

CPDA Releases Scorecard that Reviews the Design Simulation Practices of Twenty-Five Leading Edge Users

VISTAGY Introduces First Comprehensive Engineering Solution for Design, Assembly and Validation of Aerostructures

Parametric Exchange for SolidWorks Now Available on Geomagic Labs Website

PTC and French National Ministry of Education Sign Agreement to Train Engineers of Tomorrow

Spatial Delivers PMI with CAD Translation to Automotive and Aerospace Software Supplier

New Metris Articulated Arms Make Handheld Scanning Easy and Provide Accurate Data Everywhere

Delcam software used by Bowes to develop Airbus cabin interiors

ANSYS Named To CRO’s 100 Best Corporate Citizens List

OPEN MIND Presents hyperDENT CAM Solution at IDS

New Release of NEi Nastran V9.2 FEA Software Focuses on Productivity and Realism in Engineering Simulation

MSC.Software's MD Solutions Honored in China with Prestigious Awards

ASUSTek Computer, Inc. to Accelerate Electronic Product Innovation with Dassault Systèmes Realistic Simulation Solutions

Western Electronics Uses Arena Software to Control Revisions, Reduce Errors and Improve Customer Documentation Management

TraceParts Catalogs Library Reaches Autodesk Inventor 2010 Product Certification.

Radan certified for Autodesk Inventor 2010

Next-Generation Medical Device Companies Adopt Arena to Improve Their Product Development Processes

Delcam to lead £1 million remanufacturing project

2D PDF Importer for SpinFire Pro

Glidewell Laboratories chooses Delcam CADCAM software

Vought Aircraft Reduces Time and Costs With Adoption of Verisurf Software for Inspection

CAD-Integrated CAM Solutions with hyperMILL from OPEN MIND Technologies AG

Fast Turnaround CMM Laser Scanning with Focus Scan 5.2

GigaTrust Signs Partnership Agreement With Siemens PLM Software

Ramboll Oil & Gas Uses SolidWorks to Support Half of World’s Offshore Wind Power

Creaform Expands 3D Engineering Services Offer

Autodesk Recognizes IMAGINiT Canada as Americas Reseller of the Year for FY09

LMS International's Software Solutions Aid Powertrain Design (Z034)

Delcam's FeatureCAM gives five-axis profit in four months

Edgecam certified for Autodesk Inventor 2010

Schott Systeme Retains 2008 Pricing

Guess, Inc. Expands Deployment of Dassault Systèmes’ PLM Solutions to Manage Its Global Sourcing Operation

After CAD, Zucchetti chooses PLM from think3

Delcam sets new sales record in 2008

VISTAGY Partners with ITS to Extend its Leadership in the Rapidly Expanding Russian Aerospace Market

CD-adapco ATOMIC Consortium to Reduce Carbon Dioxide Emissions through the Application of Advanced Simulation Technology

Just few hours to become familiar with KOMPAS-3D

Manufacturing SKEW Measurement in Less Time

James Dyson Foundation Pitches in for Elementary School Whiz Kids to Attend Robotics World Fest

Hagerman & Company achievements honored at Autodesk One Team Conference

Tyco Electronics Inspires Next Generation of Engineers as Gold Supplier of the FIRST Robotics Competition

JETCAM launches composite material life management software

Brown Shoe Drives Global Product Development With PTC Footwear Solution

Datakit Offers New Monthly Subscription for CrossXpert Technology for CAD Data Conversion

mental images Introduces mental mill

Bluebeam Releases Bluebeam PDF Revu 7.0 for PDF Markup and Editing

SURFCAM Gallery Contest Winners Announced

Actify Expands 2D Importer Offering

Mentor Graphics Provides Complete 3D Variability Solution Addressing Density and Thickness Challenges


Related MCAD News

Featured Annoucement Introducting HP’s Z Workstations – A Quantum Leap Forward

Ford Motor Credit Company Provides Update on Tender Offers

At the Heart of Plant and Process Expertise: CAD Schroer after daratechPLANT™ 2009

3DVIA Speeds Up 3D Application and Game Development with the Release of 3DVIA Virtools 5

NASA's Lunar Rover Concept Visits Houston Robotics Competition

HP Offers Free Web Security Tool to Help Businesses Guard Against Malicious Hackers

mental ray 3.7+ Gives Autodesk 3ds Max 2010 Users Superior Shader Creation

Océ Launches Affordable High Resolution Wide Format Color Scanner

Automotive Aluminum Use Reaches All-Time High In 2009

3DVIA Announces Virtools Support for Xbox 360 Development

ATK Pioneers the Development of Materials and Processes for Manufacturing Ceramic Matrix Composites (CMC)

NVIDIA Introduces Industry's Most Powerful Professional Graphics Lineup

A. Schulman Unveils New Manufacturing Site for Plastic Additives

BOXX Enhances Advanced Visualization Computing Systems with Addition of mental ray 3D Rendering Software

Gear Technology, International Precision Gear Manufacturer, Recognized by Boeing Aerospace for Performance Excellence

Advanced Circuits Offers Free PCB Layout Software with Industry’s Largest Parts Library

Multicore Association Creates Working Group to Address Virtualization for Embedded Multicore Platforms

Flexpoint Develops Automotive Industry Uses for Flexpoint’s Bend Sensor Technology

Manage Every MicroStation Workspace

Software Helps Apparel Companies Streamline Production

Océ Introduces High Quality Range of Wide Format Color Scanners


MCAD People

David Reis Named CEO of Objet Geometries Ltd.

Andy Kalambi appointed as President for Dassault Systèmes India

Gibbs and Associates Celebrates 25 Years Thanks Customers, Employees & Partners for Landmark Anniversary

COADE President/CEO Van Laan Interviewed in Pump Engineer Magazine Discussing Today’s Challenges for Plant Designers and Engineers

Gephardt, Earley Join Ford's Board Of Directors


Industry Events

SolidWorks & GoEngineer Exhibit at WESTEC

Longview Advisors Announces New Workshop for CIC '09 Event

ESPRIT 2009, by DP Technology, at the MicroManufacturing and NanoManufacturing Conferences& Exhibits, Bloomington, Minn., April 1-2

Delcam to focus on customer success at EASTEC

ESPRIT 2009 by DP Technology at the 11th China International Machine Tool Show Beijing, China, April 6-11

Coordinate Metrology Society Celebrates Their 25th Conference

Mazak and Delcam to hold productivity seminars

Cimatron to Demonstrate New Version at WESTEC 2009

Concepts NREC’s David Japikse to Present on Turbo-performance Modeling at SAE 2009 World Congress

VISTAGY Emphasizes the Importance of its Partnerships with Industry Leaders at JEC Composites Show 2009

KOMPAS-3D for Mechanical CAD at Hannover Messe

DP Technology reseller CIM Integraters opens new ESPRIT CAM Center office in Houston, Texas

Geometric to Launch CAMWorks 2009 at WESTEC

European Automotive Simulation Conference to Drive Next-Generation Vehicle Design

Autodesk Extends Invitation to Join Webcast of Annual Investor Day

ESPRIT 2009 and ESPRIT Mold v10 by DP Technology to be exhibited at Intermold 2009, Tokyo, Japan, April 8-11

CD-adapco Announces Strong Growth at STAR Conference

Delcam to promote CAM software and services at MetalTech

Intercim Live Paris Focuses on Closing the Loop Between Engineering and Production

Connect on Collaboration at the Viewpoint Americas 2009 Users' Conference

Webinar on Axial Compressor Optimization

Delcam to show integrated machining and inspection at Control

Webcast: Enhance Packer Seal Safety Using Engineering Simulation Methods During Design

CimatronE Users to Showcase Sophisticated Parts at Eurostampi

Delcam offers free online ArtCAM demonstrations

Cimatron Group to Showcase New Versions of Software at Intermold Korea

ModernTech Mechanical Launches Simulation Seminars Series


Corporate Newsletters & White Papers

Free 3D Scanner Whitepaper: Selection Criteria for Common Applications – Download Whitepaper Now