In short, for starters Ford has indicated that it will begin using IBM/Dassault's CATIA v5 design software -- to a limited extent -- on its new vehicle programs. The question is, should this really come as a surprise? With cars like Volvo and Land Rover now a part of its product mix, why wouldn't Ford consider using CATIA? After all, Volvo and Land Rover have both been using CATIA for vehicle design for more than a decade. So, why not take advantage of this company "know-how" in other vehicle programs?
Second, Ford has elected to standardize on Teamcenter 3.0 from EDS-PLM Solutions for its product lifecycle management needs worldwide (which isn't really that much of a surprise either, since SDRC's Metaphase, the forerunner of Teamcenter, was well-established as the product data management system of choice for many years at Ford). Actually, with PTC making some inroads at Ford; assorted versions of SDRC I-Deas and Unigraphics NX currently in use; and CATIA v5 now being tested in its new vehicle programs, the reality is that Ford Motor Company must be able to support a heterogeneous CAD environment for the foreseeable future. With this in mind, why wouldn't the automaker choose to go with Teamcenter from EDS to manage its product data? By selecting Teamcenter 3.0 from EDS-PLM Solutions as the backbone for its product lifecycle management program, isn't Ford simply making a smart move, by choosing a PLM solution that has a proven track record in its ability to support multiple CAD programs?
But for just a minute, let's put aside today's scorecard, and instead focus on just what Ford will need to accomplish with its new mix of CAD/PLM software and services down the road. A few questions that come to mind, include:
- With both EDS and IBM/Dassault now playing a role in shaping Ford's future, how does each company plan to help Ford successfully create, manage, access and reuse product lifecycle information? Specifically, how does EDS plan to help Ford integrate models or data created or managed using Teamcenter or Unigraphics NX with data created or managed by such programs as Enovia and CATIA? Likewise, how does IBM/Dassault plan to help Ford integrate models or data created or managed using CATIA and Enovia with data created or managed by such programs as Teamcenter or Unigraphics NX?
- How will IBM/Dassault and EDS assist Ford in cutting manufacturing costs? Specifically, which provider's digital manufacturing initiatives will be put in place at Ford? EDS's Tecnomatix solution, or IBM's Delmia? Or some of both? And if the answer is both, how will this be accomplished?
- How will EDS and IBM/Dassault help Ford to gain a competitive edge in terms of design and styling? Specifically, to what extent will Unigraphics NX be employed at Ford? And to what extent will Ford rely on CATIA, in particular, CATIA v5 to meet its design and styling requirements? (Some critics argue that CATIA v5 is still an immature product -- how can IBM/Dassault assure Ford that it is not going to have to contend with a software solution that isn't "production-ready?")
- With an eye on the future of automotive manufacturing -- which promises a tighter integration between design and manufacturing and a greater emphasis on manufacturability -- what does IBM/Dassault bring to the table for Ford? What about EDS-PLM Solutions? To what extent will Ford be able to take advantage of EDS-PLM offerings in this area, if its new vehicle programs are designed using CATIA v5?
- Finally, in terms of virtual prototyping and simulation (the area credited most often these days with delivering the greatest cost savings in automotive design and manufacturing), will Ford employ virtual engineering tools from EDS or IBM/Dassault Systemes? Or both?
Comments? Feedback? Email Contact to tell us what you think about this topic or if you have additional information you'd like to share on this subject!
Amy Rowell is the managing editor of MCADCafe, and the editor of MCAD Weekly Review.
- IBM, Dassault Win Ford Software Deal Wall Street Journal, 6 February 2003 ($$ - free trial available)
- IBM Inroads at Automaker Ford Deals Blow to EDS -- Reuters, 5 February, 2003
- IBM, Dassault Systemes Win Ford Software Contracts -- Bloomberg, 5 February, 2003
- IBM Deal Will Help Ford Cut Design Cost -- The Detroit News, 6 February 2003
- Commentary: IBM Wins at the Expense of EDS -- W.Bradley Holtz, 6 February 2003
- ANSYS Announces $25.3 Million in Revenue and $0.43 Adjusted Earnings Per Share for the Fourth Quarter 2002 [04 Feb 2003]
- ANSYS to Acquire CFX, a Leading Provider of Computational Fluid Dynamics Simulation Software and Services [04 Feb 2003]
- Dassault Systemes Extends Worldwide Market Leadership in PLM With Solid Fourth Quarter and Full Year Financial Performance [06 Feb 2003]
- EDS Awarded Expanded Product Lifecycle Management (PLM) Software Contract For Collaboration and Product Creation By Ford Motor Company [05 Feb 2003]
- EDS Board of Directors Approves 15-Cent Dividend on EDS Common Stock [05 Feb 2003]
- EDS Reports Results for 2002 Fourth Quarter, Full Year; EPS 75 Cents for Fourth Quarter of 2002; $2.28 for Full Year [06 Feb 2003]
- EDS Response to Ford Motor Company Statement [06 Feb 2003]
- IBM and Dassault Systemes Awarded Contract for Worldwide Vehicle Development by Ford Motor Company [06 Feb 2003]
- MSC.Software Announces Release of MSC.Patran 2003 [04 Feb 2003]
- Applied CAD/CAM, Inc. is Presented With the 90/90 Club Award and the Presidents Club Award at SolidWorks World 2003 [31 Jan 2003]
- Avatech Solutions Issues Proforma Financial Information Following Its Merger With PlanetCAD [31 Jan 2003]
- CAD Graphics West Enters into Strategic Reseller Agreement with Capvidia [05 Feb 2003]
- Capvidia Becomes Official Supplier for Audi [06 Feb 2003]
- CEA and ANDRA Order Services from Open CASCADE To Integrate the 'ALLIANCES' Simulation Codes [03 Feb 2003]
- Corporate Profile for Alibre Inc., dated January 31, 2003 [31 Jan 2003]
- EdgeCAM Puts the Seal on Machining Efficiency [04 Feb 2003]
- EDS PLM Solutions President Tony Affuso to Keynote Fifth Annual Solid Edge Global Summit [03 Feb 2003]
- Engineous Software Releases iSIGHT Version 7.1; Network Publishing Allows Remote Clients Access to Published iSIGHT Applications on Server Machines [05 Feb 2003]
- ESI Group Announces PAM-CAST 2002 [04 Feb 2003]
- Framework Technologies Achieves Another Record-Breaking Quarter [05 Feb 2003]
- Fuel Tech's Acutiv Software Group Announces the Availability of ACUITIV. Version 3.2 Visualization Software for Computational Fluid Dynamics Models on Windows. 2000 [05 Feb 2003]
- INCAT Launches Verifi(TM) for CATIA(R) V4 - V5 Migration [31 Jan 2003]
- John Alpine Named CTO of CoCreate Software [03 Feb 2003]
- MatrixOne Introduces New Professional Certifications to Ensure Successful Implementation of PLM Solutions [07 Feb 2003]
- NC Postprocessing Tools Provide Vital Link to CNC Machining Centers [03 Feb 2003]
- PTC Pro/ENGINEER Wildfire Uses Groove Networks Technology To Create Industry-Leading 'Contextual Collaboration' Offering [03 Feb 2003]
- PTC'S Pro/ENGINEER Wildfire(TM) Delivers Highest Functionality At Lower Cost Than Competition [04 Feb 2003]
- RAND Worldwide® Earns Recognition As John Deere "Supplier of the Year" [03 Feb 2003]
- SolidCAM Achieves SolidWorks Gold Certification [07 Feb 2003]
- SolidVision to provide Document Management Training to New England's Engineering Community [31 Jan 2003]
- Strategic Reach PR Takes On New Staff to Serve CAD/CAM/PLM Clientele [05 Feb 2003]
- Technology Answers Launches Ground-Breaking CAM Automation Software [05 Feb 2003]
- With Over 3000 Users, CADD Edge Maintains Ranking as Largest SolidWorks Provider in the Northeast [31 Jan 2003]