The Difference Between Industrial Design And Design Engineering

There is a huge misunderstanding between the overlapping functions in which these two processes—industrial design and design engineering—operate. The following definitions are from Wikipedia:

Industrial Design (ID) is an applied art whereby the aesthetics and usability of products may be improved. Design aspects specified by the industrial designer may include the overall shape of the object, the location of details with respect to one another, colors, texture, sounds, and aspects concerning the use of the product ergonomics.

Design Engineering (DE) is a discipline that creates and transforms ideas and concepts into a product definition that satisfies customer requirements.

The definitions of these two categories of design have a fundamental difference between them: ID is an applied art, whereas DE is a discipline. This means that industrial designers more often have more liberal control than design engineers to design everything that they or their customers like. This is due to the fact that design engineers have only one choice: make it work.

However, since the functions of each are often unclear, customers can easily be confused as to which one they need. Although, misunderstanding which one they need is almost inevitable because of a series of factors:
1. Each industrial designer or design engineer has greed to get the job, so they do not make it clear to the customer what their function is.
2. The customer looks for a “one stop shop”, so they want to accomplish everything in one shot, whereas they may need both an industrial designer and design engineer.
3. Designers believe to be something they are not. Some industrial designers believe to be design engineers as well, only to end up creating a product that is not functional or suitable for manufacturability. Whereas, some design engineers believe to be industrial designers as well, only to end up creating an ugly product that requires a three-armed person to use it.

It is both the industrial designers and design engineers’ job to educate customers. If we compare them with doctors, doctors have done a much better job in educating their customers (patients) about their specialization. You never have a cosmetic surgery doctor performing brain surgery (or vice versa) due to the differences in specializations (and liability). It is very clear on what one can and cannot do. Unfortunately, it is not as clear what one can and cannot do in ID and DE. Therefore, it is a big mess.

When I started in the plastics injection molding industry 26 years ago, I was fortunate to be taught then the difference between ID and DE. And so, as a design engineer, I have always been careful not to step into the ID area. My job is to design a working product and send that to an industrial designer to dress it up.

Having worked with different customers of different backgrounds, I realized that industrial designers and design engineers very rarely recommend that their customers see the other (unlike doctors do). This is a matter of pride and business. There is a fear that the customer will think one is incompetent or that the customer will finish the project with the other one, although unbeknown to the customer the other one is not the expert in both.

I consistently receive product designs from industrial designers, in which case 99% the parts are not ready for manufacturing. They most often times need a draft angle added in order to eject the part from the mold or a wall thickness increased to accommodate the material specification. Somebody has to spend the time to redesign the part, and that has to be paid for by the customer. Often times, the customer does not understand the need to redesign and the sequence of events to validate. This situation creates confusion, frustration, and mistakes.

When a customer pays for a design, they expect the design to be ready for manufacturing. However, many times customers find themselves paying more and waiting longer for product redesign so that it is suitable for manufacturing. Therefore, know the difference between industrial design and design engineering, and ensure you know which one you are dealing with.


Agjah Libohova
Director of Research & Development
Autronic Plastics inc.
29 New York Ave
Westbury, NY, 11590
Ph: 516-333-7577
Fax: 516-333-7695
E-mail: Email Contact
Website: www.apisolution.com

Rating:
Reviews:
Review Article
  • An engineer's viewpoint...here's another August 30, 2017
    Reviewed by 'Tony Stark'
    Ok, let's get the ubiquitous CV out of the way first: design engineer for far too long, company director, CAD expert and instructor, top grade degree from top university, patents, awards, customers included Automotive OEMs and leading product design consultancies, someone took a nice photo of me once. Currently taking a sabbatical from work to study a PhD, because those letters will look nice on my business card eventually.
    In my experience you can always tell how creative a role is by how offended someone gets when you try to describe their profession in any simple terms (and I have many close friends and colleagues working in industrial design that would agree). Design engineers are less creative and therefore much more boring people. You wouldn’t want them at a dinner party, but they’d care less about getting an invite (and I have many close friends and colleagues working in engineering design that don’t get out much).
    So, my simple definition: an industrial designer will produce a design, for a design engineer to ensure will work.
    An engineer can design a product that will always work, but maybe no-one will ever want. Industrial designers will always design stuff that looks great and everyone wants, but you’re never sure if it will work. For that reason it’s best to have both. Try to be someone who thinks they’re good at both, and most top design consultancies will assume you’re not the best at either…and they’d be right
    How much involvement each role will have is completely dependent on the product, the company or companies responsible for the design, and the industry. Each role will have specific talents that the other doesn’t either fully appreciate, or sometimes even know about (see above article), but they are both critical to successful projects.
    Industrial designers are attention whores, engineers are just jealous they're not as pretty.
    For a more detailed description look them up in Wikipedia, don’t pay too much attention to what either an industrial designer or a design engineer will tell you, because they generally have only got half the facts, and an overinflated opinion of themselves

      Was this review helpful to you?   (Report this review as inappropriate)


  • Still a bit of a misunderstanding May 01, 2017
    Reviewed by 'Product Design Space'
    Your article is insightful. However, it is quite inaccurate to define a whole industry with your singular experience. Not all Industrial Designers are created equal. Many companies now hire industrial designers to be key strategists, design researchers, ethnographers, and business systems strategists. Their job is not to make anything look "pretty" or as you mention "dress it up." It is to do formulate the requirements of products, systems, and services from a human-centered POV. This comes before any engineering takes place.
    As mentioned above in another review, it is somewhat offensive to the industry to say that an industrial designer's job is to just an "applied art" and "dress it up."
    You may want to investigate companies such as BCGDV, Microsoft Inclusive Design, IDEO, Frog Design, Tesla, Smart Design, RCA, RISD, ArtCenter, Standford D-School, etc. They all convey a different definition and role for the Industrial Designer.

      9 of 10 found this review helpful.
      Was this review helpful to you?   (Report this review as inappropriate)


  • So both go hand in hand March 24, 2017
    Reviewed by 'Lavender Trails'
    I found that both r incomplete without each other....still from customer's point of view they seem to contradict this fact.....but all I can say is an industrial designer needs to know the work of the other as well to make the design work but necessarily need not interfere in an engineer's work.

      One person of 3 found this review helpful.

      Was this review helpful to you?   (Report this review as inappropriate)


  • Industrial Design and Engineering January 23, 2017
    Reviewed by 'Joe Martone'
    I have been an industrial designer for more than 25 years and hold BS in Industrial Design and hold an MBA from Rensselaer Poly Tech. I have led global teams of designers and engineers and I an expert in materials and processes. Finally, I have developed products across numerous industries and hold more than 35 utility and design patents.
    The title Industrial Design is confusing and often misunderstood. It is improper and offensive to describe Industrial Designers as the ones that "pretty things up".
    For me, Industrial Design is the synthesis of engineering, design and business perspectives in the development of successful products. Success is measured in dollars but also in brand strengthening and consumer satisfaction. by these measures, I have been immensely successful.
    If we were to turn the table (as devils advocate) an Industrial designer would say that a design engineer will refine the design (provided by ID) to ensure the most efficient use of material and details related to mold gating etc. Further, they must get permission to alter the design intent.
    Please note that unlike engineering, Industrial Design is not "standerdized" and that different schools have vastly different programs that range from pure "art" to others that are founded in mechanical engineering. when evaluating a new hire for a project or a position, it is wise to gauge what skill set you need (perhaps based on our current capabilities) and evaluate the candidates body of work.
    I suggest that there are many paths to new product development and that on requires a broad range of skills to not only cross the finish line, but to do so with grace. This may be the result of one or two highly (cross functionally) skilled people or by teams that collectively have these skills.
    Finally, regarding draft.
    Often, the first pass at a new design requires freedom to explore new structures, shapes, materials, mechanisms, etc.. Many Industrial Designers will provide "unencumbered" concepts (where draft and even assembly methodology is undetermined) to measure interest by the client or end user with an expectation of future refinement. This is NOT my approach or the approach of my staff. I hold that opportunities for creative solutions are revealed when one understands relevant molding/ forming and manufacturing constrains. It also saves time and money in the long run.
    Thank you for the article, I agree that we need to clarify what these titles mean, but we must also avoid minimizing the importance of each other's expertise.
    Best Regards.


      17 of 17 found this review helpful.
      Was this review helpful to you?   (Report this review as inappropriate)


  • Big Difference Between Industrial Design and Design Engineer September 04, 2016
    Reviewed by 'Austin Stark'
    I have a bachelor’s degree in Mechanical Engineering and a masters in Industrial Design. In engineering school students are not really taught how to design products. Engineering students are taught a lot of math and science. In the process they become very good at breaking problems down. When an engineering student graduates and is asked to design products they are going to make products that meet specifications, that will not break and can be manufactured. They are not very good at making products people want to use. I guess sometimes industrial designers think that they can do design engineers jobs because if a product does not require calculations then the education an engineer has completed has really only indirect benefits. These indirect benefits include being able to break down a problem very well and understanding physics much better than their Industrial design counterpart. An industrial designer could not be a design engineer at a place that sells lifting beams because that requires calculations to make sure the beam does not break and no one dies. Design engineering in my opinion is applied science and math.
    Industrial designer’s education teaches them how to create experiences that connect with the products user. Industrial designers do this through understanding the users’ needs and wants. They create objects that are aesthetically pleasing easy to use and ergonomic. They learn how to innovate and create new products that solve users’ needs and wants. Engineers do not have the training to make aesthetically pleasing objects. They are much more focused on what makes the most logical sense in terms of money savings and physics. Since emotions are not logical engineers can completely ignore emotions therefore making products that no one wants to use.
    I do not think that designers and engineers understand the need for the other profession because they think so differently. Doctors have the same med school education then they break off into specialties. An industrial designer might be focused on art his whole life and then majors in industrial design. An engineering student might be focused on math and sciences his whole life then majors in engineering. There is little overlap in education.
    Both Engineers and Designers can be very innovative, but one deals with user experience and the other deals with making things work. There is a little overlap, but without training in both nether can come close to being able to do what the other does. A lot of people have talked about the importance of the intersection of humanities and the sciences. When you combine engineers and designers that is what you get. Both are most effective when they work collaboratively together.


      17 of 17 found this review helpful.
      Was this review helpful to you?   (Report this review as inappropriate)


For more discussions, follow this link …
Rand3D

Featured Video
MCAD Corporate Newsletter
rss feed
Jobs
Mechanical Design Engineer 3 for KLA-Tencor at Milpitas, CA
Sr Mechanical Design Engineer for Medtronic at mounds view, MN
Senior Mechanical Engineer for BAE Systems Intelligence & Security at Arlington, VA
Urban Designer - Urban Design/Planning for SERA Architects, Inc at Portland, OR
Geospatial Systems Administrator for BAE Systems Intelligence & Security at arnold, MO
Geospatial Analyst - Senior for BAE Systems Intelligence & Security at Springfield, VA
Upcoming Events
ESPRIT World 2018 at Indianapolis Marriott Downtown 350 West Maryland Street Indianapolis IN - Jun 11 - 15, 2018
HxGN LIVE 2018 at The Venetian Las Vegas NV - Jun 12 - 15, 2018
IMTS2018 International Manufacturing Tech Show at McCormick Place Chicago IL - Sep 10 - 15, 2018
Kenesto: 30 day trial



Internet Business Systems © 2017 Internet Business Systems, Inc.
25 North 14th Steet, Suite 710, San Jose, CA 95112
+1 (408) 882-6554 — Contact Us, or visit our other sites:
AECCafe - Architectural Design and Engineering EDACafe - Electronic Design Automation GISCafe - Geographical Information Services TechJobsCafe - Technical Jobs and Resumes ShareCG - Share Computer Graphic (CG) Animation, 3D Art and 3D Models
  Privacy PolicyAdvertise